Preface
The anime "Mobile Suit Gundam" has already been boldly adapted into a manga, as evidenced by the work "Mobile Suit Gundam THE ORIGIN".
This "THE ORIGIN" is not just a simple comic adaptation; the setting and plot have been significantly altered, and the descriptions are more detailed, making it practically a new work.
This work provided a detailed depiction of the One Year War and Char's past, and the film adaptation further clarified it to the point where it was almost canon.
And while "Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam" hadn't been adapted into a manga for a long time, it finally began serialization in 2011 as "Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam Define."
Like "THE ORIGIN," this work is not simply a manga adaptation of the anime, but a bold remake, which is a major distinguishing feature.
As the word "Define" attached to the title suggests, I felt that this work was full of enthusiasm for "clarifying" and "defining."
Manga "Mobile Suit Gundam CDA: Portrait of a Young Comet" (by Hiroyuki Kitazume) - Introduction and Review (All 14 Volumes)
Work Introduction
As of February 2020, this series is not yet complete (16 volumes have been published).
The story is presented as a sequel to the author's previous work, the manga "Mobile Suit Gundam CDA: Portrait of a Young Comet."
The main character isn't Kamille; the story is primarily told from Char Aznable's perspective, which is a different approach from the TV series.
In the TV series, the focus was on Kamille, a pilot, so the circumstances leading to his participation in the operation sometimes felt somewhat abrupt.
In reality, it's difficult for pilots at the operational level to see the details of how the operation was planned, so in a sense, it was realistic.
However, this work is told from Char's perspective, and he plans the strategy while talking with the higher-ups in the AEUG, so it has the characteristic of making it easy to understand why they have to attack this place.
The game also features plenty of conversations and episodes between the characters.
There are plenty of highlights, not only in the interactions between the Argama's crew members, but also in the interactions between Amuro and Char.
Furthermore, a considerable amount of effort has been put into developing the Titans, the antagonists.
In particular, Jerid, the rival character, is well-developed, with his growth process, emotions, and relationships with other characters all being vividly portrayed.
I feel that his mentor-student relationship with Laila, his interactions with the original character Major Sherry Page, and his encounter with Mauer Pharaoh are depicted in more detail than those of Camille.
While there are many original episodes, such as the perceived competence of Colonel Bask Om and Yazan, and the early meeting between Colonel Paptimus Scirocco (apparently changed because it was unnatural for a lieutenant to be leading a fleet) and the AEUG leadership, the skillful way in which these original elements fit in is what makes it stand out.
After reading this manga, you'll find yourself so engrossed that you'll even empathize with the Titans' characters.
In addition, there will be appearances of characters that connect to the era after ZZ.
Characters from ZZ, such as Roux Louka, Chain Agi from CCA, and from the Axis side, Glemmy, Mashymre, Chara, and Ilia, all make appearances again, continuing from the previous series.
Due to the meticulous depiction that consciously "defines" (clarifies) various aspects, the pacing is a little slow at times, but I think it's of a quality that even Gundam fans will be satisfied with.
My thoughts (with some spoilers)
As I mentioned in the previous section's introduction to the work, it's very interesting.
To be honest, while the author's previous work, "Mobile Suit Gundam CDA: Portrait of a Young Comet," was significant as a record of Char's journey, I didn't find it particularly interesting as entertainment.
However, while this work has the interesting premise of being based on Zeta Gundam, I found the way it clarifies aspects that hadn't been depicted before to be very convincing and enjoyable.
This is just my personal opinion, but perhaps the author is better at delving into existing ideas and providing justifications rather than being given complete freedom to write.
The aspects that might be somewhat divisive are the original characters and mobile suits.
Many of the original pilots are highly capable individuals, including Sumire Hongou, the mechanic who appeared in the previous work, and Shannon, a former Zeon pilot.
For the numerically inferior AEUG to fight on equal terms, the individual abilities of their members must be high for it to make sense, so this might be unavoidable.
However, just like in the previous film "Young Comet," the pilots on the AEUG side are so strong that it's undeniable that the tension of the battles is somewhat diminished.
Among the original characters, Major Sherry Page of the Titans is one of my favorites because she helped to deepen the understanding of various other characters.
I felt that the characters played various roles, such as Jerid's growth, Char's high level of ability, Bask's strategic vision as a soldier, and the harsh realities of war.
At first, I wasn't sure about Char's bright red, original mobile suit, the "Zero Type."
However, upon reflection, I realized that the flashy gold Hyaku Shiki that appears in the original anime is far more outrageous, so I think this is better than that.
In terms of performance and form, it has a similar feel to the Prototype Z Gundam, so I personally see it as the Prototype Z.
Overall, "Define" is undoubtedly a very interesting work, including its original elements.
I wouldn't particularly recommend the previous work, but to enjoy this one more, I think it's a good idea to read both.

Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam Define (1) (Kadokawa Comics Ace)
A compilation of manga-related articles featured on this blog
Manga "Mobile Suit Gundam CDA: Portrait of a Young Comet" (by Hiroyuki Kitazume) - Introduction and Review (All 14 Volumes)
Rakuten Market: Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam Define (1)
> To the administrator
Personally, I have mixed feelings about it.
I'm the kind of person who thinks that classic works should be left as they are, with as little alteration as possible, even if the original author is involved. So, while this manga is undoubtedly interesting, it still leaves me feeling conflicted.
The reason is that if you want to add something later, you can conveniently add an infinite number of elements to the story, even if you impose restrictions. I really don't want Tomino to do that with his Gundam series. I know it's selfish of me to say this, but that's how I feel.
THE ORIGIN is a wonderful work, and I love Yasuhiko-san, and there's no doubt it's a work of incredible quality, but I stopped watching it halfway through because I couldn't get into it.
The AI-generated Hibari Misora at the Kohaku Uta Gassen (Red and White Song Contest) was also quite frightening.
I don't mind so much when they remake and improve old, unremarkable, and boring works.
I think it's similar to when a ceramic artist smashes a piece they're not satisfied with on the spot.
If you leave or add to a piece of work that you're not satisfied with, it will remain for future generations, so even though it's a waste, you have no choice but to break it.
I fully understand the desire to revise what was lacking, add different storylines, explain things like "this is how it was," or delve deeper into the characters, but personally, I'd like the TV version of Tomino's Gundam to be treated as a work of art and left as it is.
Thank you for your comment.
Certainly, it's understandable that fans of the original work wouldn't feel good about it when various people mess with something that has already been released to the public.
My stance is that as long as entertainment is enjoyable, that's all that matters, so I try not to worry about it too much.
I believe that the Gundam series' appeal lies in the fact that it doesn't explain everything from beginning to end, leaving room for imagination and making it interesting.
Therefore, I often hear the opinion that adding various things in side stories after the fact is uncouth.
That's probably why so many people want to come up with their own interpretations.
Anyway, I'm really looking forward to the release of the theatrical version of Mobile Suit Gundam Hathaway.
> To the administrator
I'm truly sorry for making such an unpleasant comment.
The reason is that I watched the Disney movie "Coco" which was on TV just before this, and I had just seen Disney display an overwhelming pride and confidence in the works they created, so I couldn't help but compare them and made some strange comments.
Now, with COVID-19, we can't afford to worry about such things anymore. I never dreamed it would become such a big deal; the time when we were worried about things like this seems like a distant past.